Wednesday, December 2, 2015

Reviewers and open science: why PRO?

As of yesterday, our paper outlining the PRO Initiative for open science was accepted for publication in the journal Royal Society Open Science. It marks the end of many tweaks to the basic idea, and hopefully the beginning of a new era in peer reviewing: the empowered peer reviewer. The basic idea behind the PRO Initiative is that the peer relationship is fundamental in science, and it is this relationship that should drive cultural change. Open science is necessary, possible, and overdue. As reviewers, we can make it happen.

What is the PRO Initiative? Signatories on the Initiative agree that after 1 January, 2017, they will not offer comprehensive review for any manuscript that does not have open data and open materials (ie, they are placed for all to access on a reliable host, such as those listed here) or at least justifies the lack of openness with the manuscript itself. If a reviewer receives such a manuscript to review, they can contact the editor to ask the authors to fix the problem so that the review process can continue; if the authors refuse, then the reviewer should offer a simple review that focuses only on the lack of data, and does not recommend acceptance. The manuscript was incomplete, after all; it should not become part of the scientific record in that form.

Science is, of course, complicated, and so the Initiative is a bit more complicated too; read the full paper for more details. But the basic idea is that reviewers are the ones who define how to review a paper to ensure that good science is rewarded. There's nothing sacred about the current non-interactive, comprehensive review system; this makes sense in a past world where physical manuscripts were being sent through the mail. Clearly, in this world you don't want a back-and-forth between reviewers, because that would take ages. Now, however, reviewers can ask for a fix instantaneously. I have, for instance, noted that a manuscript was missing a figure, and gotten a new manuscript in a day. If a manuscript does not meet certain minimal standards, there is no reason for a reviewer to continue the review. Ask for a fix; it's your right as a reviewer.

Is open science important enough that reviewers should change the way they review? I say yes, absolutely. Ultimately, though, that is up to you as a reviewer to decide. I hope that you'll decide to stand with the other reviewers who have signed the PRO Initiative. In the coming year before the Initiative takes effect, we'll be organizing events at conferences to talk about open science. Let's change science together!

If you do support the Initiative, head over to the website to get social media avatars to show your support!



[Read the paper -- Sign the Initiative -- More resources for open science]


11 comments:

  1. These types of statements are often required when applying for a job, internship or academic program. See more management personal statement

    ReplyDelete
  2. Assignment Help online
    Try to add only relevant data and information. If you feel that you are stuck, you can take assignment help online to get a proper idea. There are several web services which can help you to find out a suitable solution to your problems.

    ReplyDelete
  3. You received a really useful blog I ave been right here reading for about an hour. I am a newbie as well as your good results is extremely considerably an inspiration for me. happy anniversary to daughter and son in law

    ReplyDelete
  4. Feel free to contact us 24/7 for all your academic related tasks. Choose your essay help expert and let you receive your essay on-time.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I loved the article, keep updating interesting articles. I will be a regular reader… I am offering assignment help to students over the globe at a low price.
    "Assignment Help
    "
    "Assignment Helper
    "
    "Essay writing
    "
    "Essay writing service
    "
    "Dissertation help
    "
    "Thesis writing help
    "
    "Write My Essay
    "
    "Do My Essay
    "
    "Hire Cheap Essay Writer
    "
    "College Essay Help
    "

    ReplyDelete
  6. I found this one pretty fascinating and it should go into my collection. Very good work! I am Impressed. We appreciate that please keep going to write
    more content. We are the assignment helper, we provide services all over the globe. We are best in these services:-

    "Assignment Help
    "
    "Assignment Helper
    "
    "Essay writing
    "
    "Essay writing service
    "
    "Dissertation help
    "
    "Thesis writing help
    "
    "Write My Essay
    "
    "Computer Science Assignment Help
    "
    "Assignment Help Soth Africa
    "
    "Assignment Writing Service
    "

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thanks for sharing this information. I have shared this link with others keep posting such information. to provide best in class law assignment help online at very affordable prices.
    "Essay writing
    "
    "Essay Writer
    "
    "Article rewriter
    "
    "Essay writing service
    "
    "Essay writing help
    "
    "Write My Essay
    "
    "Write My Article
    "
    "Essay Helps
    "
    "Write my essay cheap
    "
    "Do my essay cheap
    "

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thanks for this informative content. It’s really good. Actually, I want to share some thoughts and reviews about an Australian assignment help company in Australia and the brand name is SAMPLE ASSIGNMENT. Here, I am working as an Academic Expert. To look at our online academic assistants who provide reference assignment including Accounting, Management, Finance, IT, Economics, Computer Science, Nursing, Marketing; all Academic subjects to University Students all over the Australia or even worldwide, Here is a big online assignment help providers who help students to get HD grades according to assessment guidelines and instructions. Those who are searching fo assignment help Melbourne, Perth, Brisbane, Adelaide etc. get a touch with Sample Assignment - the No.1 Assignment provider. Any student really wants to buy an assignment at the cheapest price goes to our branded website and has a look and opts our amazing and informative services, you can avail of our convenient online assignment help and samples available on our website for free. You can download it if you want. Are you ready to get 100 out of 100 in your university assessment? We assign the best writer according to the subject for your academic problems and provide support in assignment writing services. Our Customer Care Executives are available 24*7 hours to assist you in the best possible manner. Phone calls and emails are the best methods used by online assignment maker.

    ReplyDelete
  9. you can go through AllAssignmentHelp.com reviews. It will help you to know about the services, and it will help you to know whether that site is reliable or not. This is a way of understanding the opinion of users, and it helps the website to maintain its functionality and reliability.

    ReplyDelete